Lost Landmark: Duluth’s Imperial Mill

A sketch of Duluth’s Imperial Mill, made before the structure was built. (Image: Duluth Public Library.)

Grain flowing from the Dakotas and Western Minnesota to Duluth’s and Superior’s mammoth grain elevators in the 1880s made the Twin Ports a natural spot for flour mills to flourish. In 1889 pioneer Roger Munger partnered with Bradford C. Church and T. A. Olmstead and established Imperial Mills on the east side of Rice’s Point at 600 Garfield Avenue. It would become the largest such operation on the planet.

While Duluthians had been milling flour for years at a modest capacity, the Imperial Mill—built with what was then considered an experimental design—was considered “the most complete ever built” and at six stories high was by far the largest in the Twin Ports. With crews working day and night, Imperial could pump out 1,500 barrels of flour each day in its new mill, which ran on the power supplied by a 600-horsepower Reynolds-Cross steam engine. By the end of 1889, the facility had increased production capacity to 8,000 barrels a day, an earmark its owners claimed surpassed “previous records of all other flour mills in the world.” That year Imperial built wooden grain elevators #4 and #5.

By 1892 Imperial was the largest flour mill in the world, actually producing 6,300 barrels a day. Red River wheat was delivered to the mill on railroad tracks, shoveled into the mill on one side and rolled out as flour in barrels on the other, loaded straight into vessels docked along slip # 1. It wasn’t all smooth sifting: the company was faced with labor issues, including a stoppage of production in 1892 when its packers went on strike in sympathy of protesting coopers, who made the barrels they filled with flour.

In 1894 Imperial added to its complex by erecting a barrel factory 150 feet from the mill, hiring coopers to make the company’s own barrels, the first mill in the region to take this step to self sufficiency. It didn’t help with the labor issue: in 1895 the coopers union called for a boycott of Imperial products because they made their barrels with non-union labor. It took until 1898 to settle the matter.

The Imperial Mill. (Image: Duluth Public Library.)

That same year the Duluth News Tribune ran a story of a record 24-hour milling period during which Imperial ground out 7,905 barrels of flour and would have reached 8,000 had not a clog in one of the elevators caused a ten-minute delay. This was above and beyond the Pillsbury “A” mill’s previous record of 7,100 barrels. Imperial Mills, the article read, “can turnout more flour than any two plants at the head of the lake and more than any other mill in the world.”

When the Pillsbury mill soon after claimed 9,000 barrels a day, their Duluth counterparts implied that the Minneapolis millers had cheated. Two years later Charles Pillsbury himself challenged Imperial Mills and another rival, Minneapolis’s Washburn-Crosby Mill, to settle once and for all which mill had the greatest production capacity. The question was rather silly: all three mills had the capacity of running at 10,000 barrels a day, but it was difficult, and rarely necessary, to maintain that rate for 24 hours. Nevertheless, Pillsbury wound up with bragging rights.

By 1895 at least nine other flour mills operated in Duluth and Superior, but their capacities reached no where near that of Imperial’s. And at the end of the century, only Minneapolis’s Pillsbury “A” mill could produce more flour than Duluth’s Imperial.

Unfortunately, the early part of the twentieth century also saw the beginning of a steady decline in flour production in the Twin Ports due to a number of changes that made the Head of the Lakes a less desirable place to mill flour. After the price of wheat dropped, farmers in the Red River Valley began to diversify their crops, forcing the Twin Ports mills to look further away for a grain source. At the same time railways began reducing shipping costs and made changes to tariffs, which, according to historian Patrick Lapinski, caused “a shift away from Duluth-Superior and tipping the balance toward eastern cities like Buffalo.”

The text of the Duluth Imperial Flour ad above reads: “As our airship proudly raises / on high we hear the praises / and our song the world amazes / By its truth, / For we sing of product cereal / Which makes our bread ethereal / And is known as flour ‘imperial’ / From Duluth.” (Image: X-comm.)

Consolidation also played a role. Many millers combined their efforts into one organization, the United States Flour Milling Company. The conglomerate turned out to be a bad idea. A number of mills were closed, including Duluth’s mighty Imperial Mill., which had been formally turned over to the conglomerate in 1899. By 1902 the mill was on the auction block, along with all the other mills U.S. Flour Milling had purchased in Duluth, Superior, and Minneapolis. After changing hands once or twice, Imperial was sold to Duluth’s Capitol Elevator in 1905 with one important clause: the mill could never again be used for the “handling or production of flour.”

Capital operated elevators 4 and 5 and leased the mill, first in 1905 to then-fledgling Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing—today’s 3M—who used four of the floors to manufacture “abrasive papers and cloth.” Later the F. A. Patrick Woolen Milling Company used the former flour mill to manufacture clothing.

The former Imperial Mill was demolished some time in the 1950s. The exact date is unclear as most demolition permits kept by the city of Duluth were destroyed without making microfilm or digital copies. Elevator 5 was razed in 1977; the following January a spectacular fire destroyed Elevator 4 and badly damaged an iron ore steamer berthed next to the elevator in slip #1. The elevator burned for more than seven hours, and thousand of people gathered along Skyline Parkway and other vantage points to watch the remnants of the Twin Ports flour industry go up in smoke.

___________________________________________

A variety of advertising material used by Duluth’s Imperial Mills. (Image: X-Comm)

5 Responses to Lost Landmark: Duluth’s Imperial Mill

  1. Kevin: A quick search of the web for images shows that Duluth’s Imperial Mills used an image of an African-American baker (see end of story). The company also used images of its mill and young ladies and one piece featuring the African-American baker also depicts a male baker apparently of European descent. Are the images posted above the ones you are referring to? While I can’t say for sure why they chose that image, but it was not an uncommon practice and continues to this day with Aunt Jemima and Uncle Ben.

  2. I am a postal historian researching what prompted the Duluth Superior Milling Co., in the early 1900s, to adopt the image of an African American baker for much of its advertising and stationery. Collectors of advertising covers from this era are very familiar with the image, but would welcome knowing why it was introduced and then used for decades.

  3. Hi Tony,
    Nice piece on the flour industry. I have a number of printed items from the Imperial Mill. The balloon scan in your article is a wonderful piece from a bye-gone era. Imperial was very creative when it came to advertising. I have a number of views of the Capital Elevator 5 being dismantled as well as the fire that took Capital 4. There was a lake boat docked next to it at the time of the blaze and that boat was very badly damaged as a result. I hope to include these views in our next historic photographic images release covering the railroads and heavy industry in Duluth, Minnesota. Thanks for all the great detail on Imperial Flour, among other things Duluth-Superior. Keep up the good work.
    Cheers!
    Jeff Lemke, President/CEO
    TwinPortsRailHistory.com

  4. I have a family connection to the Duluth grain industry. My gr-gr-grandfather, J.O.Milne, was an Assisstant State Grain Weigh Master. he moved to Dluth in 1890 and was also president of the Duluth School Board for a while. He was a Civil War Veteran and his name is on the Civil War Memorial at the Duluth City Hall. If anyone has info on him with the state grain weighing dept. please e-mail me at tp5756@gmail.com

Leave a reply

Menu