Milling about the train yards

How Duluth’s Railroads served the Duluth Imperial Mill

Finding real photographs of the Duluth Imperial Mill isn’t easy. Here’s an un-retouched 1890s advertising shot showing the mill resplendent in white paint taken from the top of Elevator E looking southeast. Center is the 6-story mill building flanked by the dock warehouse to the left and Elevator 4 on the right. The plain brown boxcars belonged to Great Northern; St. Paul Minneapolis & Manitoba; and the Chicago St. Paul Minneapolis & Omaha railroads. (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)

The spectacular growth of the Duluth-Superior harbor between 1870 and 1898 was very much a product of the amount of grain arriving from the Red River Valley. In 1886, James J. Hill’s Great Northern Railroad built the first truly immense grain elevator on the Wisconsin side of the harbor, boasting a whopping capacity of 2.3 million bushels. Six years later, the number of elevators there increased to ten surpassing by 3 million bushels rival Duluth’s total storage capacity of nearly 12 million bushels. Grain production on the limitless prairie was advancing so quickly that in 1890 alone, an estimated 10 million bushels of wheat had to be turned away for lack of storage facilities in Duluth or Superior. Duluth handled a staggering 19.8 million bushels of wheat in 1887 but just six years later that figured jumped another third. (For an overview of the history of flour milling in Duluth, click here.)

A similar pattern of almost exponential growth continued here until 1898, when a total of 22.1 million tons of grain were shipped from the harbor, a record that would stand for another 14 years. With this amount of grain local and accessible, flour milling became a major industry in the state. Virtually every stream with suitable waterpower sites spawned flour mills, and by 1870 over 500 of them operated in Minnesota. Although Minneapolis became Minnesota’s undisputed center of flour operations, milling remained an important local industry for many towns well into the twentieth century—including Duluth and Superior.

Here’s a typical flour mill production line of the 1890s. The man on the right slips an empty sack over the bright, stainless steel loading spout. When the full weight of the flour has dropped into the sack the flow of flour is cut off from above and the sack is simultaneously weighed. Filled sacks are then lined up to be sealed and stacked by the man on the left. The 49-pound quarter-barrel sack was the standard size. Half-sacks and quarter-sacks were also bagged, each with their own sacking machine and production line. (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)

In the late 1890s, one Duluth flour milling company made plans to sell its products not just by the bushel to the local market, but by the train load to eastern cities including Chicago, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Buffalo, and New York City. That company, the Duluth Imperial Mill, required many special “flour trains,” often made up of brand new railroad cars supplied by the railroads specifically to carry the flour. Each of these trains—sometimes 36 cars long—carried roughly 7,200 barrels of flour valued at approximately $35,000—nearly $1 million in today’s dollars.

The railroads likely provided the cars because they greatly benefitted from the deal. Railroads were paid about $3,500 to move a flour train, and since the flour was handled as a single unit—without transfer of cars along the line—only the engine or caboose needed to be changed as the train rolled off of one railroad and onto the next. This kind of special handling kept the trains intact and switching delays to a minimum, resulting in little or no damage claims.

This 1889 Perry Gallagher view shows the original Duluth Union Depot with a 4-car Duluth South Shore & Atlantic flour train parked out front preparing to leave town. The first and fourth cars carry the railroad name as their slogan. The second says, “THIS TRAIN LOADED WITH FLOUR MANUFACTURED AT IMPERIAL MILLS DULUTH.” The third car says, “BEST WHEAT, BEST MILLS, BEST FLOUR.” (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)

This system proved highly efficient. Flour trains leaving Minnesota could get nearly anywhere in the country in just three to five days. This eliminated any intermediate warehousing, further saving costs. This made certain brands of flour fresher and less expensive. In effect, the flour trains of the 1890s were true unit trains consisting of a single product that provided just-in-time (JIT) delivery of crucial goods. Both of these modern transportation concepts—single commodity unit trains and JIT—were developed well over a hundred years ago for the grain trade.

The flour mills and railroads both understood the importance of a good public image, so boxcars used to transport the flour were especially clean or in new condition. But the railroads and mills wanted to expand their market, so they came up with an idea to help them advertise to virtually anyone along the railroad tracks who might happen to see a flour train.

Standard boxcars of the day were typically painted a drab boxcar red or brown color with simple white lettering. Dozens of plain brown freight trains might pass through a community each day. Flour trains were made up of these cars too, but to make things far more eye-catching the exterior sides of each car was adorned with its own unique banners and slogans. When multiple cars were combined into a train, each car’s banner made up part of a complete statement. For example, one such special 20-car Northern Pacific train of 4,000 barrels of Duluth Imperial Flour left Rice’s Point for New York City on March 19, 1895 with a complete message on it that said: (car 1) 4,000 (…2) BARRELS (…3) DULUTH (…4) IMPERIAL (…5) FLOUR (…6) SOLD (…7) TO THE (…8) PEOPLE OF (…9) NEW YORK CITY (…10) WHO (…11) KNOW (…12) GOOD (…13) THINGS (…14) WHEN (…15) THEY (…16) SEE THEM (…17) AND (…18) ALWAYS (…19) GET THE (…20) BEST. These “slogan trains” helped usher in a new era of railroad advertising. Soon all manner of goods were identified on the sides of rail cars using bright colors, fancy slogans, and detailed artwork.

The flour mills and railroads teamed up to create a new era in advertising. Special, single-commodity (flour) slogan trains rolled from the mills to large cities on the east coast. Each car carried its own unique banner and when combined into a train the series of slogans read like a sentence from one end of the train to the other. (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)

From a physical standpoint the Duluth Imperial Mill was a distinctive six-story brick structure located on the east side of Rice’s Point, smack-dab in the middle of Elevator Row. The mill building and its nearby low level warehouse were built on wooden piles driven in 1888. During its heyday the mill and warehouse were painted bright white, symbolizing the harbor’s aspirations to become a leader in the flour milling industry. The mill quickly added Elevators 4 and 5 for grain storage. These structures were positioned directly next to each other just inland of the mill itself. (Later elevator construction kept plenty of space between these kinds of structures to minimize damage in the event of fire in any one of them.) Elevator 4, the northern-most of the two, boasted a 1,000,000 bushel capacity while Elevator 5 could hold 700,000 bushels.

Here’s another Gallagher photograph from the 1930s showing the Imperial property on Rice’s Point as the Capitol Elevator Company. The original 6-story flour mill is centered in the photo with the smoke stack next to it. Elevators 4 and 5, staggered and next to each other, are farther to the left. Capitol’s harbor-side expansion from 1916 and 1926 shows Elevators 6 and 7 to the right of the mill building. (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)

The first railroad to build a single track to serve the mill was the St. Paul & Duluth Railroad (later, Northern Pacific, then Burlington Northern, and today BNSF). The Imperial Mill was closed in 1905 thanks to nationwide consolidation. The mill was sold to the newly formed Capitol Elevator Company under the condition that the building would never again be used for the “handling or production of flour.” So Capitol operated the grain elevators and leased the mill, first to Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing (3M)—which used the facility to manufacture sandpaper—and later to F. A. Patrick Woolen Milling Company.

Here’s a March 1973 view courtesy of Basgen Photography. The tall light colored structures are Capitol Elevators 6 and 7 added in 1916 and 1926. Beyond that are the old flour mill building with the taller Elevator 4 at right and shorter Elevator 5 at left. During 1978, International Multifoods constructed Elevator Annex C-1 over the footprint of the old Imperial Mill building. (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)

A second rail line operated by the Soo Line (Canadian Pacific today) was later added to the dock, and in 1916 Capitol Elevator Company constructed a modern concrete-and-brick head house and storage building on the east side of the property. This is the oldest, tallest, and most traditional-looking grain structure that remains on the property today. In 1926 Capitol Elevator built two new elevators, Cap 6 and 7, adding 1.75 million bushels to total capacity. Eventually seven surface tracks served the two sides of the Capitol elevators. In 1947 Capitol Elevator was purchased by International Multifoods.

Little of the Imperial Mill and the elevators that serve it can be found today. Wooden Elevator #5 was razed in 1977, and #4 Elevator went up in flames on January 21, 1978. That same year Annex C-1 was constructed on the exact spot where the Imperial Mill building once stood. This brought total storage capacity up to 4,150,000 bushels. In 1991 Ag Processing, Inc. (AGP) purchased International Multifoods, and in 2008 AGP was in turn purchased by Whitebox Commodities Holdings Corp., operating under the name Riverland Ag. Corp. Ceres Global Ag Corporation purchased Riverland in 2010.

The old Imperial Mill property is now part of a system that loads approximately 35 vessels during every Great Lakes shipping season, exporting more than 20 million bushels of grain annually, and the site continues to be a vital part of the Port of Duluth’s long history of shipping grain. [Scroll down for more images.]
_____________________

Jeff Lemke explores the legacy of Duluth’s railroads every month on Zenith City Online. Click here to catch up on past installments—and visit his fascinating website, Twin Ports Rail History, here.

Here’s a slip-side view of Capitol Elevator 4 on March 4, 1976. A spectacular fire destroyed this wooden structure on January 21, 1978 heavily damaging the steam ship Harry L. Allen docked alongside at the time. (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)
Capitol Elevators 4 and 5 on March 4, 1976. The Northern Pacific tracks entered the property nearest the west end of Elevator 4. Look closely and you can see a door open for freight cars to enter the building. Soo Line gained access along the southeast side of Elevator 4. (Image: Twin Ports Rail History)

How Duluth’s Railroads served the Duluth Imperial Mill

Leave a reply

Menu